Lead Pastor
Joe Sherer
I have been a pastor since my early 20’s and I love it. I have a passion for preaching, outreach, and discipleship. My wife, Mary Lou and I have three adult daughters, and a very spoiled cat. 
Fun Facts: I enjoy reading, hunting, laughter, working in my shop, and tinkering with the 48 Chevy pickup truck I restored.
Office Phone: 717.464.2422 (ext. 2)
Associate/Youth Pastor
Eric Herr
I have attended Willow Street Mennonite Church my whole life. From an early age I felt the call of God to be an influence in the lives of young people for the sake of Christ. I have a Youth Ministry degree from Philadelphia Biblical University and have been a youth pastor here at WSMC since 2009. My wife, Heather and I have 4 children, Liam, Eden, Cora and Abel.
Fun Facts: I am very passionate about worshiping the Lord through music. I am also very passionate about Eagles football. I like eating candy, laughter, and board games, especially Settlers of Catan.
Office Phone: 717.464.2422 (ext. 4)
Church Secretary
Karen Godfrey
I have attended WSMC most of my life and have been their secretary since 2004. My husband, Matt and I married in 1987 and we have 2 daughters. I play keyboard for the worship team and enjoy relaxing with a cup of hot tea and a good book.
Fun Facts: I enjoy historical fiction, playing sudoku, and a summer walk on the beach. A long-time favorite verse is
Phil. 4:6 & 7.
Office Open Monday – Friday
Office Phone: 717.464.2422 (ext. 1)
Assistant Secretary
Mary Lou
In my 20’s I prayed for a husband who would be involved in church work, and God answered my prayer! I enjoy being a pastor’s wife and Assistant Secretary here at church. I love music and worshipping God, photography, and word games. We have three amazing daughters, Allison, Melanie and Carissa.
Fun Fact:
Chocolate and peanut butter are my favorite flavors, especially when combined… in shakes, desserts, and especially soft ice cream.
I love being outdoors and enjoy watching the animals and birds in our backyard.
Office Phone: 717.464.2422 (ext. 1)


Children’s Ministry Director
Deb Hershey
I have attended WSMC since 1999. I work part time as a registered nurse and am excited to also serve as Children’s Ministry director. My husband, Dale, and I have 3 adult children, Monica Taylor and Regan.
Fun Fact:
I love reading, going to the mountains and going to Cape May. I also love spending time with family and friends, enjoying a good laugh and making memories. 
Office Phone: 717.464.2422 (ext. 3)
Worship Director
Geanna Steinmetz

I have been involved in worship ministry since my teenage years. I love the idea that worship isn’t just something to do on Sundays, but that it is a way of life. I believe we worship God best when we love Him and love others. My husband Lloyd & I have 4 amazing kiddos. We were foster parents for a while and during that time adopted our 2 youngest children. 

Fun Facts:
We LOVE going to the Outer Banks, NC every year with my extended family. It is my favorite week of the whole year! I also enjoy crafts, playing guitar and singing, and the Eagles. (E-A-G-L-E-S, EAGLES!)
Office Phone: 717.464.2422 (ext. 3)
Worship Director Intern
Selah Drouillard

I attended Willow Street for many years, was a part of a few house churches and have been back at WSMC since 2021. For as long as I can remember, I have always loved singing and everything to do with music. When I started leading worship here, I immediately felt confident that it was something the Lord was intentionally calling me to. He has given me a heart for helping to lead others into the throne room in wholehearted worship of Him, and it gives me great joy to be able to do that here at WSMC.

Fun Facts:
I am a BIG coffee drinker, LOVE flowers, enjoy working out, love spending time with friends and family, and trying new foods.